"She's the one who told me what my name is," he replies. There are other details, too, that he doesn't believe so readily -- and herein lies the problem. Should he believe her because she feels so real or should he believe in what he feels is right? "She knows me and she said that she --"

This is awkward, being that it's personal information and he doesn't know this man. "I'm not sure I should divulge. What she told me was between the two of us."